
NYPD SHOWED RESTRAINT IN TIMES SQUARE SHOOTING
NEW YORK , NEW YORK:
Body-camera footage released this week shows NYPD Police Officers spending more than four minutes calmly trying to talk Pamela Cisneros into dropping two knives in the middle of Times Square, after she had already stabbed a 68-year-old man and fatally stabbed Erin Piacenti, a 32-year-old Bank of America vice president, in an unprovoked attack. Piacenti was on her first day back at work after five months of maternity leave, having just welcomed a daughter, Madison, with her husband Frank. Cisneros told officers, “You’re going to have to kill me” and said she was “tired of this world,” language that reads as a deliberate push toward “suicide by cop.” Officers still didn’t rush to end it.
NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch called it “an extraordinarily dangerous situation” with “countless innocent people around them,” and that’s the point. Every minute spent negotiating was a minute of risk to the crowd and to the officers themselves, absorbed voluntarily rather than shortcut with force.
That said, the outcome was a death, and the NYPD’s own Force Investigations Division is reviewing it. Critics will rightly ask whether armed patrol officers were the right responders to a mental health crisis at all, and whether four minutes of talking changes the calculus on the final decision to shoot. Those are fair questions for the investigation. But the tape shows officers who are at real risk to themselves and the public tried to avoid the ending they got.
The NPDF emphasizes that established safety protocols serve an essential purpose: protecting law-enforcement officers, members of the public, and others involved in potentially hazardous encounters. Any action that could undermine the ability of officers to adhere to those protocols should receive careful and serious review.
The National Police Defense Foundation remains committed to protecting the rights of law-enforcement personnel and promoting policies and practices that support officer safety, professional accountability, and public safety.
About the National Police Defense Foundation:
The National Police Defense Foundation is dedicated to supporting law-enforcement personnel and advocating for their legal rights, professional interests, and safety in the performance of their duties.
The National Police Defense Foundation is also the proud sponsor of the congressionally recognized “Safe Cop” program, which offers a $10,000 reward for information leading to the arrest and conviction of anyone who shoots otherwise seriously injures or kills a police officer.
Executive Board
National Police Defense Foundation
MEDIA LINKS:
Support the NPDF Legal Defense Fund
The National Police Defense Foundation is committed to protecting the rights of law enforcement officers and advocating for accountability when established safety procedures are called into question.
Your contribution to the NPDF Legal Defense Fund will help provide resources for legal support, public advocacy, and efforts to protect officers facing challenges in the performance of their duties.
Help us continue this important work.